DS research

Equine industries: Investigating human-equid relations and working conditions in a rapidly changing world; implications for welfare and wellbeing

Status
Applicant(s)
Researcher(s)
Start date
End date

Focussing on the concepts of 'animal work' and 'animal labour', this project investigates how donkeys and their hybrids contribute to and operate within contemporary industrial and urban activity – reflecting on their lived experience as they adapt to meet the challenges of a rapidly changing world. Historically, donkeys have (through their labour) facilitated the development of early pastoral societies, cities and, later, entire empires. However, the contemporary situation is unclear. Initial literature searches and internal knowledge at TDS indicates that donkeys are involved in a wide range of industries. However, currently there is no comprehensive overview of the range of industries that donkeys are currently contributing to and labouring within, nor are there detailed accounts of how certain industries are changing and presenting novel risks and working conditions, and what this means for human-equid relations, welfare and wellbeing. This project explores the critical role of donkeys in local and regional industries, identifying gaps where new insights and approaches are needed to meet the welfare and wellbeing requirements of donkeys in a rapidly changing world. 

Methodology

This project deploys a range of methods to illicit information and build a comprehensive picture of the different factors that shape, drive and characterise equid-supported industries globally. These include:
1. Desk-based review of existing literature on the topic;
2. A survey (questionnaire) targeted at relevant INGOs, local/regional partners, policy-makers and academic networks to illicit further information on the range of industries that donkeys and their hybrids are currently involved in;
3. Key informant interviews with relevant stakeholders identified through the questionnaire (above) to explore industry sites in more detail, including working conditions, welfare challenges, socio-political and economic dynamics; 
4. Utilise existing empirical material, collaborating with researchers who have previously investigated equid-supported industry sites; 
5. Where critical gaps remain, identify sites for investigation (fieldwork). This will be particularly important if we are to gain in-depth insights into working conditions, human-equid relations and equid experiences (a specific methodology would be developed in this case, likely combining welfare assessments, QBA and ethnographic fieldwork, including interviews, observations and photo/video data).

Aims

(i) Provide a comprehensive overview of the range of industries that donkeys and their hybrids are currently involved in, providing information on some of the questions outlined in the Introduction/Background (above). What does this tell us about the critical role of equids in local and regional economies? 
(ii) Investigate the industries that donkeys and their hybrids are working within, focussing on the spaces and conditions that donkeys are now expected to navigate and adapt to (identifying novel case studies). What are the implications for welfare and wellbeing? What are the dynamics between humans and equids and how do they reflect the challenges of modern industrial workplaces? What are the pressures from wider societal/ political/ environmental influences?
(iii) Build interdisciplinary collaboration and the cross-fertilisation of ideas between welfare science, animal labour scholarship, and those advocating for working equids. Equid-supported industries comprise a complex set of human-nonhuman relations and processes within specific socio-political and economic contexts and so this approach will be key. 
(iv) Explore policy implications (in terms of equids being recognised as workers and the expansion of the concept of ‘decent work’ to acknowledge the role and contribution of nonhuman animals) and implications in terms of international partnerships and collaborations with non-equine stakeholders (acknowledging the multiple social, political and economic factors at play in these complex settings). 

Factors Affecting and Contributing to Donkey and Hybrid Acquisition Decisions in the UK

Status
Start date
End date
Country

Across the stages of donkey/donkey hybrid acquisition, from early decision making through to the act of purchase or rehoming, there is potential for practices that may promote or compromise the animal's welfare.    

There is currently limited evidence behind the motivations, attitudes and behaviours of people thinking about or acting on decisions to purchase or rehome a donkey/donkey hybrid.  Identifying key factors associated with donkey/donkey hybrid acquisition may help to develop and direct support to where it is needed most.  

This study will incorporate three complementary strands of data collection to further our understanding of decision-making processes underlying the planned or actual acquisition of a donkey or donkey hybrid, and characteristics of the owned donkey/ donkey hybrid population in the UK. The first project strand (1a) will explore online platforms, including social media, to investigate the current sales market for donkeys and their hybrids. Data will be collated longitudinally enabling temporal differences, including seasonal variations, to be captured. Strands 2a and 2b focus on people who are contemplating acquiring a donkey or hybrid, or who have already made that commitment. In strand 2a a cross-sectional online survey targeting people who own or who have rehomed donkeys, or their hybrids, will be used to collect data on donkey and owner demographics, the owners acquisition process, information seeking behaviour and experience of ownership/guardianship. Strand 2b will use focus groups and semi-structured interviews, as appropriate, to provide a deeper insight into areas of interest informed by the survey data.

Methodology

1) A search of donkeys and their hybrids being advertised for sale via publicly accessible websites, social media and online auction catalogues. Details provided in the advert (location, age, sex, breed/type, colour, whether being sold as an individual, pair or group, information relating to breeding status, health status and behaviour, suitability, price etc.) to be recorded in a password protected Excel spreadsheet. Data will be recorded on a minimum of a weekly basis and for a full calendar year to get full seasonal representation.

Broad, descriptive data analysis will be employed to uncover trends and patterns.  

2a) Cross-sectional online survey hosted on Microsoft Forms aimed at both current and prospective donkey/donkey hybrid owners/guardians in the UK.  We are aiming to collaborate with a University for this part so that it is more independent and to avoid potentially skewing responses by it being solely a TDS survey.  Adopting a collaborative approach will also hopefully be beneficial for advertising and dissemination of the survey to a wider group of participants. The survey will be publicised on social media and via relevant newsletters.  Participants will be encouraged to share the survey details within their relevant networks to maximise reach.  

The survey will consist of a mix of demographic questions, closed-ended multiple-choice questions and a small number of open-ended (free text) questions.  

Key topics will include: owner demographics and location, current donkey/donkey hybrid demographic information, donkey/donkey hybrid owning timeline/history, method of acquisition, purchase price/rehoming fee, reason for acquisition, whether the donkey/donkey hybrid(s) matched their description/lived up to expectations, main sources of donkey/hybrid education/information.

The survey will remain active for 1 month, after which the number of responses will be checked and a decision made on whether to extend the time.

The data will be statistically interpreted to identify any significant patterns and relationships. Open-ended questions will be transcribed and thematically analysed using NVivo.

Survey participants will be asked if they would like to take part in a focus group / interview and details will be taken accordingly.

Survey participants contact data will be numericalised to preserve confidentiality whilst retaining contact information for those who volunteer for focus group interviews.

2b) Focus groups/interviews with relevant stakeholders including both prospective and current donkey/donkey hybrid owners/carers (to include private homes, guardian homes, educational establishments, commercial operators), along with breeders, dealers and welfare charity representatives. A purposive sampling strategy will be used to capture the breadth of perspectives and experiences.

Focus groups and interviews will be undertaken after gaining consent to do so (see attached information sheet and consent form). They will be recorded and preferably conducted online but face to face remains an option if required - subject to suitability and budget. Each focus group will likely have between 4 and 12 participants and there will likely be 3 questions posed to the group during the session.  Key topics will be determined upon trends identified within the survey data. 

Aims

To gain a better insight into the current online trade of donkeys and their hybrids and to explore key ownership variables around acquisition decisions.

Objectives

Research Questions:

What platforms are being used to advertise donkeys and their hybrids?

How many donkeys/donkey hybrids are being advertised (on average) each month and are there seasonal variations?

Are there certain types of donkeys/donkey hybrids being advertised (age, breed etc.)?  

Are there any regional differences?

What type of information is being given in adverts (health, behaviour, breeding status etc.)?

To what extent do acquisition decisions vary with owner demographics?

Are differences in acquisition decisions associated with differences in owner knowledge and understanding?

What are the drivers behind people deciding to source donkeys or their hybrids?  

What are the driving factors behind decisions to purchase versus rehome?  

Are there any keys aspects people look for when purchasing/rehoming (temperament, conformation etc.)?

Are there any trends (demographic, socioeconomic etc.) in people buying vs rehoming?

Do people tend to carry out any research before purchasing and if so, where do they go for information/advice?  

Understanding public perceptions of donkeys and donkey welfare within a sanctuary setting

Status
Applicant(s)
Start date
End date
Country

The Donkey Sanctuary (Sidmouth, Devon) has been receiving visitors since its inception over 50 years ago. To date, there has been little research to understand public perceptions of (and encounters with) donkeys on site and how these on-site experiences reflect and shape public ideas about animal welfare, including the concept of a 'sanctuary' and a 'good life' (FAWC, 2009) for donkeys. Therefore, the purpose of this research is to explore the relationship between visitor experiences, perceptions and ideas of animal welfare within a sanctuary settling. In other words, what do visitor experiences and perceptions tell us about how animal welfare is being imagined, interpreted and understood in the context of a sanctuary - and how does this potentially influence views of animal welfare outside of a sanctuary setting? This research will contribute to the organisation's strategy by informing our understanding of how visitors learn about donkeys, what they perceive as good welfare and how our educational material can help to inform their understanding of TDS work and the welfare of donkeys. It will also help us to better understand our supporters and wider visitors, and identify opportunities to engage them further in our work to improve donkey welfare, raise awareness of donkeys and contribute vital knowledge in the fields of human-animal studies and animal welfare. 

Methodology

This research applies a twofold methodology to better understand public experiences and perceptions on site, using:

(a) Emotional mapping - a participatory approach that enables the representation of subjective, emotional and/or affective responses to a space or place. This method will be used to identify emotional "hotspots" at The Donkey Sanctuary (areas that have significance for the public, physically, emotionally, spiritually) and understand these in relation to ideas/perceptions of donkeys and donkey welfare.

(2) Emplaced and mobile interviews - established methods in human geography that will be used to elicit public responses to the donkeys in the context of their environment, which will in turn, tell us something about public perceptions of donkeys and donkey welfare in a sanctuary setting. Interviews will be used alongside the emotional mapping exercise to enrich/give depth to the cartographic information.

Aims

Explore the relationship between visitor experiences, perceptions and ideas/understandings of animal welfare at a sanctuary - unpacking the concept of "sanctuary" in the process. To frame this as a question: What do visitor experiences and perceptions tell us about how animal welfare is being imagined, interpreted and understood in the context of a sanctuary? (See below for further breakdown of questions).

Objectives

RQ1. How do the public perceive and interpret the life/experience of a 'sanctuary donkey' based on their visits to The Donkey Sanctuary? What ideas do they come away with (a) in relation to donkey sentience and intelligence and (b) in terms of what a sanctuary life is like for donkeys? 
RQ2. In what ways (if at all) does the wider offering at the sanctuary (e.g. the landscape and nature, walking routes, views of the sea, the memorial aspects of the site) contribute to ideas of animal welfare and a "good life" for donkeys? Related: To what extent is the physical environment/space a factor in shaping perceptions described in RQ1? 
RQ3. What knowledge is generated on site with/by the public and how is it generated (e.g. through direct encounters with donkeys, through interactions with grooms, through information boards etc?). 

Forum theatre as a tool to promote positive donkey welfare on Lamu Island, Kenya

When targeting human behaviour change for animal welfare improvement, engaging with communities is vital. Equid-reliant communities are often resource poor, geographically isolated and disparities in literacy rates are common, presenting challenges to ‘traditional’ forms of engagement. Arts-based initiatives using non-written communication methods such as storytelling and performance, may be ideal media to convey positive welfare messages. In this study we evaluate the feasibility of using forum theatre to sensitise donkey-reliant communities regarding key welfare issues. Through a co-creation process, a piece of interactive forum theatre on donkey welfare was produced and staged for the public and in local schools. Post-performance questionnaire data were collected from adults and both pre- and post-performance data in schools to evaluate changes in knowledge and attitudes resulting from the performance. Quantitative and qualitative data were collected using Likert scales and open questions, respectively. Audience feedback was positive, with more than 90% of audiences strongly agreeing that they enjoyed the performance. More than 85% of adult respondents strongly agreed that the performance raised their awareness of three key indicators: donkey health needs; donkey welfare needs; and how much donkeys should carry. For youth audiences, comparison of pre- and post-performance measures demonstrated positive changes in the belief that donkeys feel pain, how much individuals liked donkeys and how confident they felt in identifying how a donkey was feeling. Although participatory arts-based approaches remain rare in the animal welfare sector, the study highlights the potential value of these methods in promoting community engagement for positive animal welfare changes.

Journal
Volume
34
Start page
16
Research output
Country

Donkeys working in commercial activities in Great Britain: Understanding the scale and distribution of donkeys, and key stakeholder perspectives.

Status
Collaborator(s)
Start date
End date
Country

Commercial activities within Great Britain are a significant addition to the workload of welfare teams due to concerns regularly raised by members of the public about the welfare of donkeys involved in this work. There are wide discrepancies in the recording of donkey population numbers in GB, or  appreciation for the numbers working in commercial settings. This project will evaluate the scale, distribution and types of donkey-related licensed/ unlicensed commercial activities in GB from FOI data obtained from licensing authorities. Using Animal Management System data it will also glean information about the welfare of donkeys in these contexts, why they are brought to TDS, and what our welfare teams find when they visit the premises of commercial operations. Further collaborative research will be undertaken with Manchester Metropolitan University (Helen Wadham) to ascertain the perspectives and understanding of those interacting with donkeys in commercial operations (local authority officials, vets, the business owners and the public). 

Methodology

Mixed methods of FOI requests to licensing authorities, data extraction from AMS, interviews and netnography. 

Aims
  1. To aid the understanding of donkey welfare in working contexts in GB to support those licensing and being licensed  ensure adequate care and retirement provision for working donkeys throughout their lives. 
  2. To aid the development of tools to support the public in welfare friendly decision-making when utilising commercial donkey related activities.
  3. Provide operational information to support the welfare teams in the delivery of an efficient and effective welfare service for donkeys in working contexts. 
Objectives
  1. Understand the scale and distribution of commercial operations (licensed and unlicensed) involving donkeys in GB.
  2. Investigate the roles donkeys are currently performing within businesses.
  3. Evaluate the welfare of donkeys in these contexts and what happens at the end of their working lives.
  4. Investigate the licensing process from the perspectives of licensing officials, operators of premises requiring licence, and the public.
  5. Evaluate the online discourse about donkeys working in GB using netnography.
  6. Investigate the licensing authorities, owners and the public's understanding and knowledge of donkeys, donkey perspectives and their needs.


 

Retrospective review of herpes virus positive cases at the Donkey Sanctuary, UK from 2023 to 2024

Curtis Goding
Chris Platts
Stuart L. Norris
E. McGoldrick
Joanna M. Cook
Presentation date

Background: Equine herpesviruses (EHV) are among the most diagnosed infectious diseases of equids. The type and clinical presentation of herpesvirus infection in donkeys can differ to that of horses. There is especially limited donkey-specific literature regarding gamma herpes viruses.

Objectives: The aim of this study was to retrospectively review positive herpesvirus cases in equids across 10 sanctuary sites in the south of England, examine the type of viruses identified and associated clinical manifestations.

Study design: Retrospective case review.

Methods: Identification of herpesvirus positive q-PCR results over a 15-month period from January 2023 to March 2024 through laboratory records. All descriptive statistical analysis was performed using R v4.2.1 and RStudio v2023.06.1.

Results: A total of 21 positive test results from 20 individual cases were examined. The population consisted of 19 donkeys and 1 pony, with ages ranging from 7 to 31. Sample types included nasopharyngeal, nasal, and ocular swabs, eye tissues and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). EHV-2 was identified most frequently (12/21), including once in CSF, followed by EHV-8, formerly known as asinine herpesvirus-3, (8/21) and then EHV-5 (1/21). Overall, 43% (9/21) of positive cases were associated with outbreaks of disease. Serous nasal discharge was the most reported presenting sign across all positive cases (9/21), found also in 88% (7/8) of EHV-8 cases. Ultimately 70% of all positive cases resolved, 30% were euthanised, and of those 83% (5/6) had concurrent or chronic illness.

Main limitations: Due to the study design, the dataset available for analysis is limited. Consequently, only descriptive statistics are included.

Conclusion: Herpesvirus positive cases in donkeys and ponies at The Donkey Sanctuary, UK are often associated with outbreaks and a variety of clinical manifestations, from mild respiratory signs to severe neurological, respiratory, and ophthalmic disease. Screening for EHV-1 and EHV-4 in acutely unwell donkeys may overlook virus types associated with severe and infectious disease.

Published as conference proceedings
Publication date
Volume
56
Issue
S60
Research output

Mule trains to mountain roads: the role of working mules in supporting resilient communities in the Himalayas

Working equids play a central role in mountainous communities, but their work often goes unnoticed by the wider world, with sparse documentation of their role, value, or welfare – a state which often extends to their human counterparts. Communities living in the remote Manaslu Valley, Nepal, face a number of uncertainties, including extreme weather events due to the seasonal monsoon and, more recently, the construction of a new road network. Using semi-structured interviews, questionnaires, and Equine Assessment Research and Scoping (EARS) welfare assessments, we outline the specific role of pack mules in supporting the lives of local people, explain the nuanced links between human experience and mule welfare, and gain insight into how people living in this volatile environment manage uncertainty and risk. Mule work was felt to be the ‘only option’ for a sustainable livelihood for most mule owners although, in some cases, mules had enabled respondents to diversify their income. Mule owners with more husbandry experience did not own mules in more positive behavioural states, which may suggest a lack of generational knowledge and support networks. Short-term ongoing risks, such as the monsoon or unstable tracks, had a larger impact both financially and emotionally than the long-term but distant implications of the road construction. Mule owners must constantly balance the risk of working during the monsoon season, when conditions are treacherous but pay was higher, with losing valuable income but keeping themselves and their mules safe; they do, however, have a more mobile option for employment than non-owners. Mules enable a level of resilience and agility for communities living with constant uncertainty and change, which is only beginning to be recognised formally within the sustainable development sphere. Integration of animal welfare into the SDGs would allow humanitarian aid initiatives to strengthen support networks around working equids, which would greatly benefit the mules and humans alike.

Volume
11
Publication date
Research output
Country

Donkey discourse: Corpus linguistics and charity communications for improved animal welfare

A corpus linguistic approach has been applied to examine the representation of donkeys in public discourses for an international equid welfare charity (The Donkey Sanctuary) with a view to improving the British public's understanding of the roles of donkeys, in Britain and worldwide. By increasing understanding of public perceptions, this study aims to support improvements in donkey welfare through targeted education.

The study explored patterning in public discourses about donkeys (online and print news and social media) using corpus linguistic (CL) techniques and tools, supplemented with methods from discourse analysis. The findings highlight key representations of donkeys in public and media discourses that are not present in informed discourses about the animals. In this paper, we examine the results of the corpus study from the perspective of one current aim from The Donkey Sanctuary's public engagement strategy: to promote understanding of donkeys as sentient beings with the capacity to experience a wide range of emotional responses to events or situations.

We found that donkey experience is more subtly represented in the discourses than other aspects of donkey lives, such as actions and behaviours, which have more obvious, overt representations. The results demonstrate the value of applying the CL framework for researchers and practitioners involved in textual analysis for charity communications and public awareness campaigns. We discuss the implications that our findings have for donkey welfare—and animal welfare more generally—as well as what such a methodology could offer other organisations providing public education and/or relying on philanthropic support from the public.


 

Volume
2
Issue
2
Publication date

Colitis in donkeys

The presentation of colitis in the donkey may differ from that in the horse. Donkeys typically mask signs of pain and illness, and diarrhoea is not common in colitis. Recognition, treatment and management of colitis requires an underlying understanding of donkey-specific behaviours and an awareness of differences in the pharmacokinetics of certain medications. Colitis may present comorbidly with other pathophysiology, and a careful stepwise diagnostic approach to the dull donkey is essential.

Journal
Volume
8
Issue
3
Publication date
Subscribe to DS research